What Are IRS Segment Rates, and How Do They Set Your Pension Lump Sum?
Somewhere in your pension paperwork there is a number your employer did not choose. Your lump sum offer is not a judgment call by HR; it is the output of a formula Congress wrote, using interest rates the IRS publishes every month. Those rates, the three IRS segment rates, are why two retirees with identical $2,000-a-month pensions can get lump sum offers tens of thousands of dollars apart. The difference is timing, not negotiation.
Three rates for three time horizons
Federal law (26 USC 417(e)) requires private-sector defined benefit plans to convert your future monthly checks into a present-day lump sum using segment rates tied to corporate bond yields. The payment stream gets sliced by when each payment arrives:
| Segment | Payments | Rate source |
|---|---|---|
| Segment 1 | Years 1 to 5 | Corporate bonds maturing within 5 years |
| Segment 2 | Years 6 to 20 | Bonds maturing in the 6-20 year window |
| Segment 3 | Year 21 and beyond | Long bonds, 20+ years |
Each payment is discounted by the rate for its own time band, and the three present values are added together. That sum, combined with the IRS unisex mortality table (which estimates how long you will collect), is the minimum present value: the legal floor your plan must offer. The plan can be generous; it cannot be stingy.
The worked example: $2,000 a month, three rates, one answer
Take a $2,000 monthly annuity, $24,000 a year, with a simplified 25-year payment horizon. Discount the first five years at 5%, years 6-20 at 5.5%, and years 21-25 at 6%:
- Years 1-5 at 5%: about $103,900
- Years 6-20 at 5.5%: about $188,800
- Years 21-25 at 6%: about $34,600
Total minimum lump sum: roughly $327,300. Now drop every rate by one percentage point, keeping the same payments: the total rises to about $361,800. That is a 10.5% swing from a one-point rate move, which is why retirees who retired in the low-rate years of 2020-2021 saw the largest lump sums of the decade, and why offers shrank as rates climbed.
The intuition is worth internalizing. The discount rate answers the question: how much money, invested today at this rate, replicates your pension? At low rates you need a bigger pile. At high rates a smaller pile does the job. Your lump sum is that pile, so rates and offers move in opposite directions. This is also the mechanism behind how interest rates move pension lump sums, which I covered with the break-even math.
The part your plan controls: the lookback month
Here is the detail that actually costs or earns people money. Your plan does not use "today's" segment rates. It uses the rates from a lookback month defined in the plan document, applied over a stability period. A calendar-year plan might use August rates for every retirement in the following year. That means two coworkers retiring in January and December of the same year can face the same rates, while a January retiree and the previous December's retiree face different ones.
Pension advisors call the exploitation of this "rate shopping": if rates are trending up, an earlier annuity start date locks the older, lower rates and a bigger lump sum. It only works if your plan's stability period makes the timing matter and you can actually move your start date. Check the summary plan description for the lookback month before you do anything clever. And if the offer ever looks smaller than your own math suggests, the 6% rule check is a fast sanity test.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are IRS segment rates?
Three interest rates derived from investment-grade corporate bond yields, published monthly by the IRS. Under 26 USC 417(e), pension plans must use them to discount future annuity payments to present value: Segment 1 for payments in years 1-5, Segment 2 for years 6-20, Segment 3 for year 21 and beyond.
Do higher segment rates mean a smaller pension lump sum?
Yes. Higher rates discount future payments more aggressively, so the present value falls. As a rule of thumb, a one-percentage-point move across the segment rates changes the lump sum by about 10% or more, depending on your age and the payment stream.
Can I time my retirement to get better segment rates?
Sometimes. Plans apply a lookback month's rates over a stability period, so your annuity start date picks which vintage you get. If rates are rising, an earlier start date can lock lower rates and a larger lump sum. Check your summary plan description for the lookback month first.
Is the segment-rate calculation the final lump sum offer?
It is the legal minimum. Section 417(e) sets the floor a plan must offer; plans can offer more, never less. The plan administrator combines the segment rates with the IRS unisex mortality table to produce the number on your benefit statement.
What mortality table is used with segment rates?
The IRS unisex mortality table, updated annually by IRS notice. It gives the statistical probability you will be alive to collect each future monthly payment, and the segment rates discount those probability-weighted payments to present value.
Estimate Your Pension Lump Sum
Enter your monthly benefit and age to see a lump sum estimate and your break-even age.
Calculate My Lump Sum