Pension Lump Sum Calculator

Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity: What Inflation Quietly Does to Your Choice

When my father retired, his pension check felt generous. Fifteen years later he called it his "shrinking paycheck," and he was right. A fixed pension annuity does not lose a single dollar on paper. It just buys less every year, quietly, until one day you notice the groceries cost more than the check covers comfortably. Inflation does not change the lump sum vs annuity decision. It is the lens that makes the decision clear. Here is how.

The shrinking paycheck, measured

Most private pension annuities are fixed for life. No cost-of-living adjustment, no inflation bump, the same nominal dollars every month until you die. In a 2% inflation world, that erosion is a footnote. In a world where prices run at 3% or 4%, it is the dominant feature of the choice.

Years into retirement$3,500 check at 2% inflation$3,500 check at 3% inflation$3,500 check at 4% inflation
10$2,871$2,604$2,364
15$2,600$2,246$1,944
20$2,355$1,937$1,597

Those are today's-dollars values. At 3% inflation, your $3,500 monthly annuity buys about $2,604 of groceries, gas, and medicine after 10 years, and about $1,937 after 20 years. You have not lost a dollar of income. You have lost nearly half of what it does. This is the number people leave out of the decision, and it is the one that matters most for a 65-year-old who might live another 25 years.

The rule of thumb. At 3% inflation, prices roughly double every 24 years. At 4%, they double every 18. A fixed annuity bought at 65 is paying half its original purchasing power by your late 80s. If that timeline bothers you, the fixed annuity is probably the wrong answer.

What the lump sum offers, and what it costs

The lump sum's advantage is that it is not fixed. Rolled into an IRA and invested in growth assets, it can earn returns that outpace inflation, which a fixed annuity structurally cannot do. That is the entire case for the lump sum under inflation, and it is a real one. But it comes with two risks the annuity carries for you: investment risk, because markets do not guarantee anything, and longevity risk, because you can outlive your money.

Think of it as a trade, not a free lunch. The annuity gives you certainty in nominal dollars and takes your inflation risk and investment risk off the table. The lump sum gives you a shot at beating inflation and demands that you manage both risks yourself, with discipline, into your 80s and 90s. The inflation argument only favors the lump sum if you will actually invest for growth. A lump sum that sits in a money market at 2% while inflation runs 4% loses purchasing power faster than the annuity, with none of the annuity's guarantees.

If your plan offers a COLA annuity option, price it carefully. A cost-of-living-adjusted annuity preserves purchasing power, but the starting payment is lower. Run the crossover: the COLA version starts behind the fixed version and catches up over time. With a long retirement ahead, the COLA usually wins. With a short one, take the higher starting check. Our guide to pension break-even age shows how to run that comparison.

Social Security is your inflation hedge. Remember that Social Security adjusts for inflation every year. If your pension is fixed but your Social Security benefit grows, the erosion only hits part of your retirement income. The pension decision matters less when most of your floor is inflation-protected already.

How to decide

I find it helps to frame the question bluntly: which risk keeps you up at night? If it is watching a fixed check buy less every year for two decades, the lump sum deserves serious consideration, because inflation is the one risk the fixed annuity cannot insure against. If it is the thought of managing an investment portfolio at 85 and possibly running dry, take the annuity and accept the erosion, or look for the COLA version.

Three questions to ask your plan administrator before you decide. Is a COLA option offered, and exactly how much lower is the starting payment? What discount rate was used to calculate the lump sum, because that tells you how much growth you need to beat? And does the plan impose any deadlines that would let you watch inflation trends before electing? Our piece on pension lump sum window offers covers the timing tactics when the election window is tight.

My honest read: inflation is the fixed annuity's blind spot, and most people underestimate it because the erosion is gradual. Run the purchasing-power math above with your actual check amount and your own guess at inflation. If the year-20 number shocks you, trust that reaction. It is telling you something real about which risk you actually fear.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a pension annuity keep up with inflation?

Usually not. Most private pension annuities are fixed, with no cost-of-living adjustment. At 3% inflation, a $3,500 monthly check buys about $2,604 in today's dollars after 10 years and about $1,937 after 20 years.

Can a pension lump sum protect against inflation?

It can, but only through investment returns. A lump sum rolled into an IRA can be invested in growth assets that may outpace inflation, which a fixed annuity cannot do. The trade-off is that you take on investment risk and longevity risk the annuity would have carried.

Should I take a pension with a COLA if offered?

A COLA annuity preserves purchasing power, but the starting payment is lower than the non-COLA option. Compare the crossover: the COLA version starts behind and catches up over time. If you expect a long retirement, the COLA usually wins; if your life expectancy is short, the higher starting payment wins.

Which choice is better if inflation stays high?

High inflation favors the lump sum, because the lump sum can be invested for growth while a fixed annuity check buys less every year. That advantage only holds if you actually invest for growth and do not raid the principal early.

Run Your Own Pension Math

Enter your lump sum offer and monthly benefit to see the break-even age and compare both options.

Calculate My Pension Break-Even

One retirement move a week. Short guides on pensions, rollovers, and annuity decisions. Get them by email.